More tricks by the corrupt ARIZONA STATE BOARD OF NURSING. When the judges (paid by the state, appointed by the same Gov, all eat from the same feed trough, side together ) they post it , as such. When AZBN loses they do not post or discuss in their meetings, but hide in private session illegally. The entire case is manufactured and is a results of retaliation by a dirty medical center YUMA MEDICAL . Who placed false allegations with this board . YRMC is known for doing this to nurses . (a board who’s members past and present are on staff at yrmc. ). A string of liars brought in, 1) testified she is nurse (she is now on AZBN nurse imposter list ! ) . A felony. She also made up many stories to save her employer from being sued. This case has NOTHING to do with mental anything. This is old tricks they love to pull on anyone who goes against them . Just sign up a bunch of court whores , like Phillip Lett and they will say can benefit for counseling (due to Minch being the victim). but this is how the corrupt AZ board of nursing like to put a spin on things. Minch refused to sign, to sign , a pack of lies. More integrity than the board. A board run by a cult one one sided thinkers and willing to destroy a good nurses career to protect their fellow board members and their hospital . They certainly have a pattern.

Minch quit this underhanded medical center, sued the harasser and won , a unemployed drug selling tenant , drug in by a nurse living in their apts they own . When yuma medical mess got wind they filed a false report with the AZBN (SIX months after Minch quit. ) . To distract her from suing yuma med center. AZBN had NO business taking on a case that the nurse did NOTHING WRONG. But many of the so called lying witnesses did , and have felons to start with .


***Appealing a sham court, OAh, where A judge heard the entire matter , AFTER closing arguments and hearing over , Minch was told , “a new judge was assigned ” . HUH! Then a few weeks later , Minch was told “a new judge was assigned, THIS IS NUMBER #3 Judge (the latter two were never in the court room, never saw any witnesses ) The 3rd Judge a Bishop Mormon, cult member signed and made those who committed perjury ‘credible” The opinion all written by the corrupt AZ Board of Nursing.

Don’t be fooled by their public bashing bullying and lies , the prosecutor told Minch’s atty “the whole thing is bull shit”. So is she , not even checking out their own witnesses , to see if the ‘nurse expert ‘ is a nurse at all !!

The EX DIR of the BON has a complaint of unprofessional conduct during her working hours. The dirty atty went to the AZ BON with a new policy and had them vote for it, any complaints on BD staff or BD members would be dealt with by HER !

(The EX DIR hired HER (EMMA MAMALUY , talk about dirty back room tricks ! ) EX DIR JO RIDENOUR should be taken out of this position immediately . Her case should have been in front of the board. Unprofessional, unethical, and downright nasty.

They will tell you public safety , that is not what they are doing . 25 years stellar record. This can happen to anyone and has to many, they just don’t talk about it.

Exposing this corruption , and a board that just keeps taking turns and protecting each other is a shame . All of this expense , at the taxpayers dime. NO OVERSIGHT , no one is watching , not even the Gov. SHAMEFUL . !

AZ Board of Nursing Punitive, Inconsistent.

When a young man goes to nursing school , just graduated , excited to start working as a nurse , and applies for a license so he can start his new career. When an old dui showed on his record. <most states do nothing first time dui>. It is an off duty , isolated event. He went to the AZ Corrupt board of nursing meeting, his family his support system, had moved to Calif he moved there and wanted to start working , asked for withdraw his application in AZ . Simple enough . NOT when your dealing with the crazies at the AZ BON. It was McCormies (Carolyn) who kept throwing a wrench into telling other bd members her CONCERNS . She is always mistrusting of every nurse, every nurse is lying to her. Her Concern is that he will not tell Calif about the Dui, (like Calif doesn’t run back ground checks on nurses !! ) So it was decided at previous meetings, he would get it in writing from them they are aware that they know about it and will deal with it when his license is processed. Not only did he tell Calif with proof, but BONNIE RICHTER (the Bd investigator in AZ contacted Calif BON). This is a violation , they are not suppose to be disclosing information and it was not her duty to do so . AZ over steps their authority all the time . This New nurse is dealing with his DUI and will pay the price there dearly. He got verification from Calif that they are aware of his DUI. Then the corrupt az bon brings up , that there was no signature or date stamp , even though Bobbie stated Calif knew. He had a very hard time getting a hold of them . So AZ BD doesn’t trust any nurse to disclose what he already disclosed to them . (Quite frankly it is not AZ jurisdiction to board order him to do this , non of their business to “protect public in every state ). And makes him come back to the BON meeting, pay atty again, and prove to them that Calif knows.

Now the dirty atty’s for the BON , Emma Mamaluy and staff download what they want the BON to vote on. A consent agreement for 36 months probation. If not signed deny license. So Smith <sometimes she has some good questions > board member said and what are we going to have him sign agreeing to probation in AZ when we know he can’t do that living in Calif. ? Then the question why cant we let him withdraw license. Of course Punitive Puke McCormies , spouts off , ‘what if he withdraws his license in Calif and goes somewhere else ? (like every state in the union does not do a back ground ? Really. Unless they get him to sign consent agreement, for 36 months 3 yrs !! probation they will deny him license. Which is what Jo Elizabeth Ridenour decided , “it will be a lot cleaner if you deny license , instead of setting him up for something he cannot do ” . Oh really ! !! like DENYING A LICENSE won’t ruin your nursing career for years, to reapply in another state, AND ruin your chance for ANY JOB . When I tell you do NOT work or apply for a nursing license in AZ , this is how they operate !! NOT all boards do. Every one of those boards member do not care , they get paid for those investigations and do not want it wiped out , they want to have punitive records , lots of them . And then all in the name of public safety . Yea right ! The new nurse thanked them , and hung up, he was obviously upset. His lawyer tried. Everyone on this dirty board voted how their dirty director told them to, and Mccormies, who pretended she did not want to vote against him , after she was the one making waves all along, the only one . Her make up is that she is thrilled to have the power and stop the other board members before they let some nurse who doesn’t even live in AZ anymore, withdraw and get on with their life in another state. Start a new career and realize people make mistakes but congratulations on completing nursing school and get him on a fresh start . SHAME ON YOU DIRTY BITCHES , everyone of you who voted to deny license. You did a lot of damage to this poor man , while your lies about public safety are wearing thin. Especially shame on Hill who allowed others to change her mind , too easily she has no back ground It will come back to you ten fold. Karma’s a bitch too.


This is a BIG deal, huge. If you do not know anything about mormons, you may be shocked to learn how they infiltrate into your nursing career.

They do not drink coffee, who cares why , but drinking alcohol, is not their thing and so they judge you by their bringing up . Which consists of huge doses of brain washing. ! A recent case , a man surrendered he had a dui. They ordered a psych evaluation, he admitted he had had a glass of champagne on New years and a glass of wine at a birthday party. ONE GLASS , the evaluation showed NOT ADDICTED . the mormon board president (and the former bd president MORMON) UH !! Carolyn McCormies, says the dumbest things, and will ruin you for life . Stated she has CONCERNS , that he is still drinking . (two drinks in 3 years folks !! ) not kidding. She went on about he admitted that he is STILL DRINKING .

So , is he suppose to not have a drink for the rest of his life / career of nursing in AZ??

Pick up a mormon book, they tell them all bad things are satan driven. They have a strong dislike for homosexuals. Beware , if you go before this board , they love to control and run everyone’s lives, and over step isn’t the word . just crazy .


Sad how they are all alike , and how they act. The mormon’s do this to nurses too!

Verbally , abusive dehumanizing tactics .

— Among the centers is Provo Canyon School, where Hilton spent almost a year and claims she was “verbally, mentally and physically abused on a daily basis.” … And they were physically abusive, hitting and strangling us. They wanted to instill fear in the kids so we’d be too scared to disobey them.”

Attorney General Office Taking Nurses licenses in Arizona , unduly .

There are few crimes as egregious as an oath taker lying , in my opinion. Wrongful accusations leading to wrongful prosecution leading to wrongful conviction and wrongfully destroying a nurses good reputation and paint a very bleak picture of man’s inhumanity to man. One person making false accusations against another is bad enough, but to have a system that not only allows and facilitates that, but even encourages false accusations leading to false and wrongful revocation , is absolutely intolerable.” I would add false allegations and a corrupt board include INNOCENT nurses , cna’s , NP , whistleblowers, veterans, and other “vulnerable” Americans. Thus, we are ALL vulnerable to falsehoods and false imprisonment in our own homes, through various ways . Robbing nurses of ability to earn a living in many fields after the false accusations give rise to revocation by a corrupt board of nursing. All of this abuse is perpetrated and facilitated by the “legal” system in the United States. And, therefore, ALL Americans need to rise up and speak out against such abuse and misuse of power. Learn more about the motives, incentives, benefits and profits to the abusers, and say , stop this injustice now.

AZ Nursing agency (azbon) corruption

Anyone who decides to get a nursing license in AZ , we would first advise against it . Way to dangerous . Many nurses think , that an anonymous complaint will never rise to losing their career .

Once you are on your way to a board complaint, you are up against a lot. Not only does the AZ BON contribute to a unduly complaint and charges but they make us unable to see or comprehend the errors as they are happening.

It is against what all of us were brought up to believe in justice, due process and the system . When you look at the cases and see nurses who took unreasonable and intellectually dishonest positions that stripped the innocent nurses of their freedom and caused tremendous human suffering for entire families.

Don’t beat yourself up thinking , they haven’t seen the truth or know what really happened , they do not care . The AZBON are trained that you are the liar , every defendant nurse is lying , and guilty of something . They must psych themselves out that they are actually doing ‘good’ for the public. They cannot accept they are wrong . When you prove their allegations to be wrong , they refuse to acknowledge it and have a knee-jerk reaction . They refuse to examine any new evidence and will come up with outlandish theories in order to maintain their deep-seated beliefs about the systems fairness . <which does not exist>. And make up new issues to argue and wear you out , trying to cause you to mess up at work, give them something solid .

You can watch the prosecutors , Elizabeth Campbell and Sunita Krishna the way they spin the new evidence in ridiculous ways to avoid conceding innocence. When one tries to go into a court room, the prosecutors are in such denial that no one in their office has ever taken a license of someone who is innocent . This defensive attitude not only is unjust it wastes tons of taxpayers money . They will fight back for years on the taxpayers dime to save face.

The prosecutors are not going to approach any case with an open mind , but would use any means available to them to intimidate a witness from testifying . The ALJ’s are in on it, only allowing end of day last minute quickies . With the writers of the recap of the hearing written by liars working at the BON, never making any of the defendant nurses ‘witnesses ‘ credible , only the BON witnesses. To the reader who wants to see what the case is about they have no idea just how dirty these board employees and members are . Once the hearing officer deems someone credible it is very hard to reverse that in other courts .

Human beings have a very hard time changing their minds once the die is cast. Nothing happens in happenstance, it is all done by those who have stripped other nurses of their humanity and will do it again, over and over.

Good people generally act with goodness WHEN ACTING ALONE. But will do things unthinkable when involved in a large bureaucracy. Where they are just a cog in the wheel , doing ‘what they are suppose to do”. No single person can be seen as the cause of any single injustice . responsibility is defused . The system is responsible not the individuals , or so they THINK . The nurse / np will know who the front runner is . When they retire they will have a lot of time to reflect what a dirty life they lived and how many people they hurt in many ways. That day will come when things so down and a name appears that you with other people’s money , stole from them like a con artist at work , with a BON who are politically motivated to do the dirty tricks, and crooked judges, helped the matter .


This Rn , JD lived in MANY places . One of them was several places in AZ. She was hired by Jo Ridenour to work at the BON, she was nothing but a disaster. Did she humiliate nurses , dehumanize to get a raise ? For her own self do some nasty tactics while at the Board of Nursing agency. ? No one who has a caring bone or any feelings for anyone but themselves can justify her behavior .

Hired as a nurse practice consultant, investigator . Taking cases that had little to do with nursing but just a bunch of people who want to retaliate against someone , finding out they have a nursing license , contact the BON to get them in trouble cause them grief. Only because the AZ BON has way too much power , and no one watching them . Knowing how opening an investigation would cause many days of hardship.

Did you think the nurse would not know you called their professor !??? That was YOU acting like the ones who put in the complaint in the first place , trying to cause trouble !

Anyone who knows her lives by her works with her, BEWARE , a wolf in sheeps clothing for sure . Her ex , former friends in Colorado , AZ have all been stung by this venomous bitch .

And when she tells you , sour grapes and why the nurses lost their license , remember SHE IS LYING ! .


Looking over a few cases and the A Cobia case, a few things to point out, that the Arizona Corrupt board is more than willing to go along with and allow to happen. Even though the attorney’s have a duty to ensure fairness and when a manifest injustice occurs’ correct it. And may be added to the appeal , of the judges errors.

The case law from April Cobia’s case , we see the judge did not wright anything about the issue of the Administrative Law Judge frustrating Cobia’s efforts to question the witnesses , by multiple interruptions…. Depriving Cobia’s efforts to strategically question the witnesses, and concentrate on her defense and what needs to be brought out into evidence by this witness… Nothing was mentioned at all on this matter…. Its like she never even raised this as an issue…
On her Mandatory Reporting issue…
Notice the case law twists the review, as it states the issue is unprofessional conduct based upon —- failed to notify her supervisor she called Cornerstone. But in the review, the judge never identifies the employers of NPA’s *****policy or law**** which makes it mandatory for her to notice her supervisor she called cornerstone…. Apparently, there is no such policy or law…… the statute he used. was simply that the A.A.C. R4-19-403(9) states:: ” stating unprofessional conduct includes failing to… follow policies and procures of the nurses employer designed to safeguard the patient.. The judge never stated any employer policy which was noticed to Cobia nor in existence at the employer….. This was an improper denial…… Cobia should have won on this issue….
Cobia’s religious discrimination issue, from what the judge rights, is as looser…. can’t win this one…. Never ever seen a Judge ask a defendant to tell the court if they are a certain ‘religion” or currently practicing . ! Absurd !
Cobia’s falsified documents issue , the reviewing judge was correct, its the ALJ’s duty to review all evidence and draw all inferences… BOTH COBIA’S CASE AND THE CITED Aguayo V. Indus. Common, v 235 Ariz. 416 (app. 2014)..

The hearsay issue, this is a loosing issue… and went toward denial as a result.
The due process issue, to cross examine the. witness, we’ve already covered above….
The HIPAA ISSUE, I feel the judge twisted this to fit a denial as she was using her home computer to do her work, and I’m guessing the employer knew of this home computer use for patient data….. This was within the bounds of the law and HIPAA in my opinion, and arguable on appeal to a higher court. A ‘consultant, Millbren, told me she ( with the AZ BON) practices entirely from her house, what is the difference ?

Cobia’s sufficiency of evidence issue, the judge twisted this into. Cobia’s PAST EMPLOYMENT HISTORY…. Cobia’s Credibility!!!! He evaded the issue….
The rest of the judges comments are focused on bashing Cobia’s credibility….. and making her out to b a menace to the public….. This makes me believe the State/BON Agents wrote this opinion and got the judge to sign it, and move onto the next case file…. this saved this judge time…. This is all to common and a travesty of justice.

Revocation, well this is harsh but I would imagine those board members are pretty callused and could cut someone’s eyeballs out and make an excuse why it is the right thing to do and how many members of the public they helped by doing so. !